Activists say US human rights report “biased”, overlooked violence and key issues
UNB
Publish: 18 May 2024, 04:03 PM
Dhaka,
May 16 (UNB)--Members of the civil society, human rights advocates, and leaders
from minority communities have expressed shock and dismay at what they termed
the United States's "over-reliance" on dubious sources in its most
recent human rights report. Critics are particularly alarmed by the US report's
seeming endorsement of political freedoms for Jamaat-e-Islami, an entity they
say has consistently opposed the foundational values of Bangladesh and, prior
to the last election, explicitly aimed to establish Sharia law in the country.
Haroon Habib, a
distinguished rights activist heading a national coalition of war heroes,
criticized the US for its apparent support for Jamaat, which continues to
honour individuals involved in wartime atrocities.
"Advocacy for such
a group demonstrates a profound hypocrisy in the US approach to human
rights," stated Habib. He also pointed out the lack of US recognition for
the genocide during Bangladesh's 1971 Liberation War, despite acknowledgment
from numerous international entities including the Lemkin Institute for
Genocide Prevention.
This omission, according
to Habib, starkly contradicts the Biden administration's proclaimed commitment
to upholding human rights globally.
The report's glaring
omission of violent incidents, such as arson attacks on public transportation
and brutal killings of law enforcement officers, reportedly orchestrated by
BNP-Jamaat activists under the directives of Tarique Rahman, has also drawn severe
criticism. Rahman, the acting chief of BNP, who is currently residing in the UK
and has been convicted on multiple charges including money laundering, was also
noted for inciting street violence months before the national election, urging
followers to "decide the fate of the country on the streets" rather
than through democratic means.
Adding to the
controversy, the US report neglects significant allegations against Odhikar, a
local human rights organization. Odhikar's leadership, including Secretary
Adilur Rahman Khan and Director ASM Nasiruddin Elan, had been previously
criticized for producing a report deemed biased and flawed following violent
events in Dhaka in 2013, described by a mainstream English newspaper as a
"composition of half-truths, biased and one-sided presentation of what
happened on May 5 and in the early hours of May 6 in the capital."
Shahriar Kabir, a
renowned Bangladeshi journalist and human rights activist, recounted his
interactions with American policy experts at a meeting organized by the
Atlantic Council. Kabir observed a disconnect between the US policymakers'
perceptions and the realities in Bangladesh.
"It seemed that
there was a considerable lack of awareness about the scale of Jamaat's
atrocities," Kabir noted, expressing frustration over the US's tendency to
equate Jamaat with legitimate democratic political parties.
Rana Dasgupta, another
vocal rights activist and leader from the minority community, sharply
questioned the integrity of the US report, criticizing its dependence on
"biased sources" that misrepresent Bangladesh.
"Such citations
attempt to lend credibility to sources that are fundamentally flawed, thereby
undermining the overall credibility of the US itself," Dasgupta added.
END/UNB/MK/KW
