Arab American voters make their choice: Harris, Trump or neither
UNB
Publish: 29 Oct 2024, 12:36 PM
DEARBORN,
Oct 29 (AP/UNB) - Bowls of labneh and platters of za'atar bread covered the
tables in a Lebanese restaurant near Detroit, yet no one seemed to have much of
an appetite.
On one side were Kamala
Harris ' top emissaries to the Arab American community. On the other were local
leaders who were explaining - once again - why many in the community couldn't
vote for the vice president because of the war in Gaza.
"I love this country,
but I'll tell you, we have never been so disappointed in this country as we are
now," said Nabih H. Ayad, chairman of the Arab American Civil Rights
League. "We wanted to give the Democratic Party the opportunity to do
something, and they haven't."
"The one line we
can't cross," Ayad said, "is genocide."
Nasrina Bargzie and
Brenda Abdelal, who were hired by Harris' campaign to spearhead Arab and Muslim
outreach, listened intently but said little in response.
If Harris loses Michigan
and the presidential election next week, it's conversations like this one that
could explain why. The Detroit area has the country's largest concentration of
Arab Americans, and Democrats fear that Harris will pay a steep political price
for U.S. support for Israel, which rejects allegations that its military
operations in Gaza constitute a genocide.
Community members who
normally back Democrats said they face an impossible decision. Either they
punish Harris for what they view as complicity in the deaths of at least 43,000
Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, or they endure Donald Trump
's return to the White House, which they fear would revive discrimination
toward their community.
A reminder of the
situation's complexity came in Ann Arbor on Monday night, when Harris held a
campaign rally. Assad Turfe, one of the few Arab American elected officials in
Michigan to endorse the vice president, said his community needs someone
"who sees us, who understands us and who will give voice to our pain,"
adding that "without a doubt that Kamala Harris is that leader."
But as Harris began her
remarks, pro-Palestinian protesters interrupted by chanting, "Israel
bombs, Kamala pays, how many kids have you killed today?" Harris
responded, "hey guys, I hear you" and "we all want this war to
end as soon as possible."
It's unclear how many
skeptics Harris will be able to win over, especially since she has not proposed
any concrete changes on U.S. policy toward Israel or the war in Gaza. Four
years ago, Joe Biden won by a 3-to-1 margin in Dearborn, where nearly half of
the 110,000 residents are of Arab descent. Now Democrats are concerned some of
these voters will go to Trump or third-party candidates like Jill Stein.
"They're split.
There are those who will vote for Harris, recognizing that they could get a
seat at the table," said U.S. Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., who convened the
recent meeting at the Lebanese restaurant in his efforts to help the Harris
campaign. "But there's a chunk that will vote for Stein or stay at home.
Then there's a minority who will vote for Trump."
Trump has secured a
number of endorsements from Muslims in the area, including from two Democratic
mayors who represent Muslim-majority cities outside Detroit. He brought several
Muslims on stage at a rally in metro Detroit on Saturday.
He argues he will put
"a stop to the endless wars" and notes the Abraham Accords that
Israel signed with several Arab nations during his presidency. He has also
mocked Harris' embrace of former Rep. Liz Cheney, a conservative Republican
whose father, former Vice President Dick Cheney, was a key force behind the
U.S. invasion of Iraq. Harris is campaigning with Liz Cheney to try to pull
away moderate Republicans turned off by Trump in Michigan and elsewhere.
But many top Arab
American leaders - even those who have not endorsed Harris - are still deeply
negative toward Trump and say his endorsements don't reflect a majority of the
community. They also remember his call for a "total and complete shutdown"
on Muslims entering the country and his travel restrictions on visitors from
Muslim-majority countries. And some point out that Trump has suggested that he
would give Israel even more leeway to attack its rivals in the region.
Harris wins over someone
who backed the 'uncommitted' movement
Turfe, a Lebanese
American and the deputy executive of Wayne County, is among the few Arab
American leaders in Michigan to have endorsed Harris. He says it's to ensure
the community doesn't return to a Trump presidency that "opened up old
wounds for the generation that lived through those post 9/11 years."
Turfe said he was jolted
awake by immigration agents in 2005 when they came to detain his wife, who had
come to the country when she was 2 years old and was unaware that she didn't
have legal citizenship.
"They came for her
and they ripped my family apart," he said.
Then in 2006, Turfe's
two grandmothers were killed in Lebanon as Israel fought with Hezbollah in a
war backed by President George W. Bush.
Turfe said his community
was primarily Republican until those years. But members moved toward the
Democrats during Barack Obama's presidency and then helped Biden beat Trump in
2020.
Those political bonds
are now ruptured.
Hamas attacked Israel on
Oct. 7, 2023, killing 1,200 Israelis and kidnapping more than 200 hostages.
Israel launched its offensive shortly afterward with military and diplomatic
support from Biden's administration.
As civilian casualties
mounted in Gaza, anti-war Democrats in Michigan and elsewhere launched a
protest vote movement in the Democratic primary. They garnered over 100,000
"uncommitted" votes, with the majority coming from the state's
Muslim-majority cities like Dearborn.
Turfe was part of the
"uncommitted" movement while Biden was running for reelection, but he
said he changed his mind when Harris became the nominee. He endorsed her in
August and met her before a rally near Detroit in October.
He said he told Harris
about his grandmothers' deaths nearly two decades ago, and "I felt her
empathy."
"She felt my
pain," Turfe said.
Turfe's endorsement has
sparked a backlash. On social media, photoshopped images accuse him of
endorsing atrocities in Gaza. He's also received text messages labeling him a
traitor. Longstanding relationships in his hometown of Dearborn have become
strained.
Dearborn resident
Suehaila Amen is accustomed to having her community in the national spotlight,
having starred in the 2012 TLC reality series "All-American Muslim."
A lifelong Democrat, Amen said she won't be voting for Harris.
"They want to send
their people to come and scope and see how we're feeling because now they're
scared that they're going to be losing a swing state," said Amen, who
lived in Lebanon from 2017 to 2021. "But, you know, if she loses, it's by
her own doing, by her own hand, and she'll deserve it."
Amen said she doesn't
want Trump to win but "I have to, at the end of the day, sleep at
night."
Harris makes her closing
argument to Arab Americans
Harris made a rare
reference to Israel's fight against Hamas and Hezbollah during a recent speech
in Oakland County, outside of Detroit.
"This year has been
very difficult, given the scale of death and destruction in Gaza and given the
civilian casualties and displacement in Lebanon," she said. The death of
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, she said, "can and must be a turning
point."
Harris also said she is
"very proud to have the support" of Turfe and other Muslim leaders.
But Harris has not
called for any reduction in the flow of U.S. weapons to Israel, and her
campaign did not allow a pro-Palestinian speaker to take the stage at August's
Democratic National Convention, a key demand of the "uncommitted"
movement.
Khanna, a progressive
Democrat from California, has stayed in close contact with Arab American
leaders in metro Detroit for months and received the "Profile in
Courage" award from the Arab American Civil Rights League this summer.
Khanna is Hindu but said his family's background has given him shared
experiences with Arab Americans.
During the Oct. 26
meeting with Arab American leaders, Khanna sat next to Harris' Arab and Muslim
outreach directors while acknowledging that "not enough" has been
done by Harris to help end the Israel-Hamas war.
"If Trump is
elected, people like me won't be in any of the rooms," Khanna said.
"Harris gives people like us a seat at the table to advocate for
you."
It's the kind of message
that resonates with Mike Musheinesh, a Palestinian American who runs his own
auto parts store and attended the meeting. He said the community should vote
for Harris "even if we have to hold our nose."
"If we want a seat
at the table, we need to help her over the finish line," he said.
End/UNB/AP/MB